Cedar Oils vs. Stains vs. Water-Based Products: What’s Best for Your Timber?

When it comes to maintaining the natural beauty of cedar cladding, choosing the right treatment is essential. The harsh New Zealand climate can take its toll on timber, so selecting the appropriate product will not only enhance your exterior’s appearance, it will also extend its life.

At Clayton Gibson Concepts, we specialise in high-end cedar care, and one of the most common questions we get is: Should I use an oil, a stain, or a water-based treatment? Here’s a breakdown of the key differences and when each option makes sense.

1. Cedar Oils

Best for: Natural, breathable finishes with a traditional look.

Cedar oils penetrate deep into the timber, nourishing it from within. They’re designed to enhance the grain and tone of the wood, offering a rich, natural finish without forming a surface film.

Pros:

• Enhances the natural look of cedar

• Allows the timber to breathe

• Easy to maintain with reapplication

• Migrates deeply into the timber

Cons:

• Requires more frequent maintenance (usually every 1–2 years)

• Slower drying time

• When oil has a colour tone, the colour will stay the same after each maintenance coat

Our verdict: Ideal for clients who want a low-sheen, natural aesthetic and are happy to maintain their cedar regularly.

2. Timber Stains (Solvent-Based)

Best for: Colour enhancement with a protective layer.

Stains add colour and offer more UV protection than oils, while still allowing the wood grain to show through. Solvent-based stains are more durable than oils, making them a popular choice for exposed timber.

Pros:

• Adds colour while showcasing timber texture

• Offers moderate UV and water resistance

• More durable than migrating oils

• Available in a wide range of tones

Cons:

• Colour tone may get darker with maintenance recoating

• Penetrates until it dries and may penetrate up to 3-4mm

• Not as breathable as oils

Our verdict: Great for clients wanting a stronger protective barrier and more tonal control, especially in high-sun or exposed areas.

3. Water-Based Products

Best for: Long-lasting protection with modern technology.

Water-based stains and coatings are becoming increasingly popular due to their eco-friendly formulas, fast drying times, and enhanced UV protection. These products sit more on the surface of the timber, forming a protective film.

Pros:

• Excellent UV resistance (with added cool colour tint)

• Faster drying and easier clean-up

• Low VOC (eco-friendly)

• Can last longer between recoats

Cons:

• Can create a slightly artificial or less “natural” look

• Is prone to flake or peel if not maintained regularly

• Less breathable than oils

• Is susceptible to cupping or twisting

Our verdict: Ideal for those looking for lower maintenance and strong protection, especially on contemporary homes with a crisp, uniform finish.

So… Which One Should You Choose?

That depends on your home, your climate, and your desired look. At Clayton Gibson Concepts, we assess each project individually, considering factors like exposure, timber age, and architectural style before recommending the right treatment.

• Want a soft, natural look? Choose an oil

• Want colour depth and protection? Go with a stain

• Want longevity and low maintenance? Consider a premium water-based product

Need Professional Advice?

We’re specialists in timber preservation and high-end finishes across Queenstown and beyond. Whether you’re maintaining existing cladding or protecting new timber, we’ll guide you toward the best solution and apply it with precision.

Get a Quote